Turkey
Economy: Lira Lurches
The fall in the value of the Turkish lira in recent
weeks and the accompanying dip in equity prices have
come as no great surprise, given the evident need
for a correction in the country's financial markets.
However, domestic political factors and trends in
global markets have sharpened the adjustment, and
brought an increased risk of damaging consequences
for the economy as a whole. Remedial steps by the
authorities should stabilise the lira in the short
term, but we expect further instability later in the
year.
Since May 8th the Turkish lira has been in almost
continuous decline, losing almost 15% against the US
dollar and the euro. The correction was long overdue.
The real effective lira exchange rate appreciated by
almost 40% in 2002-05, which, combined with strong
domestic demand and rising international oil prices,
has seen the current-account deficit balloon to 6.5%
of GDP last year and increase by almost 40% in the
first quarter of 2006 compared with a year earlier.
The fall was triggered by the unwinding of carry
trades (short dollar positions that have been used
to fund investments in high yield countries) as
investor sentiment turned negative towards Turkey (and
other highly indebted emerging markets). This change
of mood has occurred despite the government's
impressive disinflation record, its strong fiscal
performance and a commitment to structural reforms
in recent years. However, the lira was always going
to be vulnerable given Turkey's large government
debt, its burgeoning current-account deficit,
substantial external debt-servicing and heavy
reliance on short-term capital inflows.
In addition, several domestic factors have
contributed to the size of the recent fall and the
prolonged uncertainty regarding the future level at
which the lira will stabilise again. In March the
government delayed the appointment of the new
central bank governor, creating doubts about the
future independence of the Central Bank of Turkey
from political influence. After a prolonged stand-off
between the prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan,
and the president, Ahmed Nezdet Sezer, the latter
finally approved the appointment of Durmus Yilmaz,
an existing board member, as central bank governor
at the end of April. At its first meeting under the
new governor, the monetary policy committee decided
to cut interest rates by 25 basis points, reducing
the overnight borrowing rate to 13.25%, despite the
gradual rise of consumer price inflation since the
beginning of the year.
In a further blow to market confidence, on May 10th
Mr Sezer blocked several articles of the social
security reform laws, which are needed to help to
check the steady rise in the social security deficit.
The IMF has been awaiting final approval of social
security reforms before agreeing to release the next
credit tranche under the May 2005 standby agreement.
Even though the government could bypass the
president's objections by passing the bills again
unchanged, the delay increased uncertainty among
investors and probably contributed to the initial
fall of the lira.
EU doubts
Periodic domestic political tensions and potential
obstacles to Turkey's EU membership bid in the
coming months have also contributed to the change of
investor sentiment. Accession negotiations, which
were officially opened in October 2005, are
considered an important anchor for the political and
economic reform process in Turkey over the medium to
long term. To ensure that the negotiations move
forward in the short term, however, the government
will need to produce clearer evidence of further
progress on human-rights reforms, particularly on
the Kurdish issue, than it has done in recent
months. In addition Turkey has to ratify an
additional protocol to its existing customs union
agreement with the EU, which would oblige it to open
its ports and airports to Greek Cypriot ships and
aircraft by end-2006. Turkey has so far refused to
do this, arguing that any implementation should be
tied to measures to facilitate direct trade with the
EU for the Turkish Cypriots in the north of the
island, something the Greek Cypriot government of
Cyprus has not accepted.
Murder in court
The murder of a Council of State judge by an
Islamist extremist on May 18th also exacerbated lira
volatility, as it increased fears of a destabilising
collision between the government and the secularist
establishment, which includes the president Mr
Sezer, the judiciary and the military. They view Mr
Erdogan's Justice and Development Party (AKP) with
suspicion because of its Islamist roots. Secularists
attacked the AKP saying that its criticism of the
court's ruling in favour of the ban on the wearing
of Islamic style headscarves in schools,
universities and public offices had encouraged the
attack. In return, the AKP criticised the Turkish
Armed Forces chief of staff Hilmi Ozkok's praise of
secularist street protests after the murder.
IMF mollified
Faced with continued financial market turmoil, the
government agreed on May 22nd to IMF demands for
spending cuts of US$3bn to help to meet its 2006
fiscal targets. The social security laws appeared to
be back on track to obtain final approval so that
the third and fourth tranches of IMF credit worth a
total of about US$1.9bn should be released by July.
This should help to stabilise the lira in the coming
months. But we expect further tightening of
international liquidity and higher inflation in
Turkey to contribute to a further fall of the lira
to around TL1.65:US$1 by the end of this year,
before a stabilisation in nominal terms in 2007. In
the medium term maintaining the momentum of the
reform process will prove increasingly challenging.
The temptation to loosen fiscal policy or even
abandon the IMF agreement may increase as the next
election due in November 2007 draws nearer.
|